Getting Kids Offline
Are Facebook and Instagram like cigarettes? Like Doritos chips? Like the slot machines in a casino?
Humans love an analogy. I sure wanted one to help process yesterday’s news that Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, had settled with 47 states, agreeing to pay up to $17.1 billion in penalties and change its products to make them less addictive and dangerous for children.
All three metaphors work, but cigarettes are probably the most apt, given legal proceedings and fines that recall the battles over Big Tobacco in the 1990s and early 2000s.
Don’t focus on the money, though. Mike Isaac, who reports on big technology companies, told me that right away. The penalty’s the least important part. Meta made $200 billion in revenue last year. A $17 billion fine amounts to what he called a “speeding ticket.” Wall Street didn’t see it as a crippling sum — Meta’s stock went up.
Focus on the changes instead. They run counter to Meta’s business interest, which is to keep users on its platforms for as long as possible.
Eli Tan, one of our tech reporters, ran through them.
Time limits. Users under 18 will get just two hours a day on the apps, and none at all between midnight and 6 a.m. Notifications won’t be sent during school hours. Spend 15 consecutive minutes on Instagram or Facebook and a prompt will appear on the screen (though Meta didn’t say what the prompt might be). There’ll be another prompt at 60 minutes of use, and again at 90 minutes.
Disabling features. Teens will for the first time be able to turn off “autoplay” for videos and to turn off their algorithmic, personalized feeds. “Like” counts will also go away. Young users will no longer be able to use filters that alter their appearance with digital makeup or cosmetic surgery.
Stronger protections. Meta said it would introduce ways to prevent “unwanted contact from strangers,” though it did not lay out how that would work. It said there would be a new way for teens to report harmful content on the apps, and promised that it would respond to those reports promptly. It said the company would improve tools parents can use to monitor what their children are doing on the platforms.
Age verification. This is a big one. The whole enchilada rests on its effectiveness. And it’s unclear, beyond a promise to do a better job of making sure its users are who they say they are, just how Meta’s going to do it. Remember that in 2025, Australia implemented a social media ban for kids under 16. Teens quickly found workarounds.
Far from over
Now we can get to the money. Mike made a great point about it yesterday. “Meta is on the hook for $17 billion only if other companies — namely TikTok, YouTube and Snap — also agree to make these changes.” (Right now they’ve agreed to only $12 billion.)
And of course those companies are not legally required to do that. Meta wants them to, though, for its own good. Here’s Mike:
If Meta has to reduce the amount of time it’s allowed to keep young people using its apps and TikTok, Snap and YouTube do not, that’s a significant competitive disadvantage. Wrapped in the florid language of setting “a new industry standard,” Meta wants to get every tech company — both those that exist today and any future ones that are yet to come — playing by the same set of standard rules, lest it eventually fall behind.
I asked him if he thought it would work. “It might,” he said. “Imagine being TikTok or YouTube and saying, ‘No, thanks, we don’t want to protect kids,’ as Meta puts you on blast online.” Here’s his article about the deal.
More on the Meta deal
THE LATEST NEWS
Nepal Floods
IN ONE CHART
President Trump has endorsed at least 260 candidates for Congress and governor this election cycle. So far, only nine have lost. Read about his endorsement strategy.
OPINIONS
Hayden Panettiere worked in front of cameras before she was 1 year old. The child acting system is unethical and exploitative, Alison Pill, a former child star, argues.
15
— That is how old Dean Roy is. He enjoys Formula 1 racing, says he gets good grades and works part time at his parents’ pizza shop. He’s also running for governor of Vermont. (Yes, he’s eligible.) You’ll want to meet him.
SPORTS
College sports: SEC officials approved stiff penalties for any programs that violate new rules about transfers. And any N.F.L. players who return to college will be ineligible for future drafts.
Tennis: The U.S. Open confirmed that Venus and Serena Williams would earn a wild-card entry into the doubles bracket. Also, the 2016 men’s champion Stan Wawrinka is getting his own wild-card spot after some backlash.
Sue Li’s recipe for a black pepper beef and cabbage stir-fry makes for a fantastic weeknight dinner. Double it so there are leftovers to tuck into a sandwich the following day for lunch, with a swipe of mayonnaise. That’s living.
WHAT MADE DOLLY SPECIAL
Wesley Morris took a look at Dolly Parton’s other showbiz career, her brief but unforgettable run as a movie star. In her films — “9 to 5,” “Steel Magnolias” and “The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas,” to name a few — she played women who were authentic. In fact, he writes: “Parton put that word out of business decades ago. All we should discover on its dictionary page is her photo.”
Read the whole thing.
More on culture
“I became fully convinced the Mets were the team of a downtrodden underworld of artists and radicals, with the Yankees representing the contemptible dominant ideology,” A.M. Gittlitz writes in a new book about the underdog New York baseball team. So of course we had to go to the ballpark with him.
Lily Friedman is a 95-year-old pianist with more than seven decades of experience behind her. Is it time for her to retire? “All these famous guys say they stop while they’re ‘on top,’ and I don’t know how you know when you’re on the top,” she told The Times. “Because I don’t feel I’m on top yet.”
THE MORNING RECOMMENDS
Test your knowledge of current dating lingo. Don’t DTR. Take our quiz.
Read “The Blue Flame,” George Pelecanos’s first novel in nearly a decade, featuring Derek Strange, his D.C. cop turned private detective. Our critic calls it “a book about aging, and about the tools still at your disposal when youth is a long-ago memory.”
Get serious about blending — whizzing up smoothies, soups and emulsified dressings — with the best blender tested by the meticulous sauciers at Wirecutter. (I know it’s expensive. Look online for a reconditioned unit.)