‘Below Deck’ alum Colin Macy-O’Toole jumps to co-star João Franco’s defense after arrest: ‘Tragic situation’

“Below Deck” alum Colin Macy-O’Toole is speaking out on João Franco’s arrest, claiming he believes his friend was trying to keep the peace amid a fistfight that led to a 17-year-old’s death.

“Having seen the video footage, my impression is that João appeared to be trying to defend himself and de-escalate an already escalating situation,” Macy-O’Toole, who was not present for the altercation, told Page Six.

“From what is visible, it doesn’t look to me like he was looking to start a confrontation. It looks like he was reacting to what was happening around him.”

Colin Macy-O’Toole told Page Six he hopes people reserve judgment after João Franco’s arrest. (Pictured: Macy-O’Toole and Franco at BravoCon 2019.) Instagram/colin_macyotoole

Macy-O’Toole worked as a junior deckhand with Franco, who was the lead deckhand, during Season 3 of Bravo’s Mediterranean Sea-based yacht show. They also filmed together during Season 4, where Franco served as bosun.

The two have remained close over the years, with Macy-O’Toole even referring to Franco as “my personal hairdresser and one of my best friends.”

“Knowing João, I think it’s important that people take the full context of the footage into consideration before jumping to conclusions or assigning blame,” Macy-O’Toole continued. “This is an incredibly tragic situation, and I hope the facts are allowed to come out before anyone rushes to judgment.”

Franco and Macy-O’Toole (seen above) are “best friends,” the latter previously said. Joao Franco/ X

Franco, 36, and his brother Karlos were arrested in Turkey after an altercation with employees outside a clothing store in the Bodrum district of Muğla on Saturday night.

Things quickly turned physical, and in CCTV footage exclusively obtained by Page Six, Karlos — wearing a dark T-shirt, shorts and a baseball cap — appeared to throw the first punch.

João — wearing a white collared shirt, shorts and a baseball cap — seemingly tried to break things up as others jumped into the chaos.

Surveillance footage shows an altercation involving João and Karlos outside a store in Bodrum, Turkey. Obtained by Page Six
Karlos appeared to throw a punch as João seemingly intervened in the escalating brawl, footage obtained by Page Six shows. Obtained by Page Six

After several failed attempts to de-escalate the situation, João appeared to swing his fist, causing one of the men to be knocked to the ground.

Local outlets reported that the person on the ground hit his head on a set of stairs. He was reportedly one of the store’s employees that night.

Voices Newspaper subsequently reported that the teenager sustained a severe head injury and went into cardiac arrest. He was revived by emergency medical responders before being transported to Muğla Training and Research Hospital in critical condition.

On Monday, Haberler.com reported the teen died of his injuries at the hospital.

João appeared to try to defuse the situation as the argument turned physical (pictured). Obtained by Page Six
João (seen during season 4 of “Below Deck Down Under” in 2025) and his brother are awaiting next steps after being arrested. Fred Jagueneau/Bravo via Getty Images

João and Karlos are currently behind bars after appearing in court.

Sources told Page Six the brothers are “awaiting next steps” in their case.

Reps for Bravo, the municipal police in Bodrum, and the local prison and court did not return requests for comment. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *