Flatiron Building nears sellout as wealthy buyers race to claim a rare piece of NYC history

New York’s most-photographed landmark just became its hardest apartment to snag.

Nearly every unit publicly listed for sale at Manhattan’s famed Flatiron Building has already found a buyer, cementing the century-old triangular landmark as the most sought-after residential conversion in Manhattan just as it prepares to open its doors this fall.

Of the 22 residences StreetEasy has shown as listed for sale at 175 Fifth Ave., only four remain unsold, putting the building at roughly 82% absorption on its public listings. That kind of pace for a building still finishing construction has stunned brokers who track the city’s luxury new development pipeline, where units routinely sit for a year or more before finding takers.

The Flatiron Building has quickly become New York’s hardest apartment building to get into because almost every listed unit has already found a buyer. Sergii Figurnyi – stock.adobe.com
Out of 22 residences put up for sale on StreetEasy, only four remain unsold today — representing an 82% sales rate. Stephen Yang for NY Post
The building just topped a major weekly luxury contract report for the second week in a row. Adrian Gaut

The latest proof came last week, when the Flatiron Building notched its second straight appearance atop Olshan Realty’s weekly contract report.

Unit 17-North, a four-bedroom spanning 4,626 square feet with a 63 by 27-foot great room overlooking Madison Square Park, went into contract asking $23.95 million. Its final price, as well as its forthcoming owner, are not yet known until the deal closes.

It marks the second time in three weeks that a unit inside the building has claimed the No. 1 spot in the report, a rare feat for any single address. It’s also one that puts the successful conversion ahead of the ultra-exclusive new-construction towers it finds itself competing against for the city’s wealthiest buyers.

Few buildings anywhere carry the instant global recognition of the building’s razor-thin silhouette, a shape so famous it lent its name to the entire neighborhood surrounding it. Built in 1902 to a design by Daniel Burnham, the 22-story tower spent well over a century as commercial office space before Macmillan Publishing, its last major tenant, moved out in 2019 and left the building largely vacant.

A massive four-bedroom apartment known as unit 17-North recently went into contract after asking a staggering $23.95 million. Visualization One
This famous 22-story tower was originally built way back in 1902 and spent over a century working as commercial office space. Visualisation One
Prices for these 36 special homes start at just under $11 million and go all the way up to $58.5 million for the top penthouse. Visualization One
Buyers are even combining units, like one person who bought the entire seventh floor for $30.5 million to make a single giant home. Visualisation One / Courtesy of The Flatiron Building

What followed was a saga befitting the property’s outsized reputation. When the Flatiron Building’s owners couldn’t agree on its future, the property went to auction in 2023, where a little known bidder named Jacob Garlick won with a bid of $190 million and then vanished without ever putting down his deposit.

A second auction that spring produced a winning bid of $161 million from those existing owners, which then partnered with the Brodsky Organization to reimagine the office relic as residential real estate.

The developers tapped Studio Sofield to handle the interiors, a decision that has become central to the building’s marketing pitch. The firm reworked the awkward angles created by the building’s wedge-shaped floor plates into a layout of one north-facing and one south-facing unit per level, plus two sprawling full floor residences on the top two stories.

To support its new residents, the historic structure is being packed with modern luxuries like a fitness center and a 60-foot lap pool. Visualisation One
The building will be home to spa-like bath retreats. Visualization One
People will finally be able to move into their new apartments this fall, while the rest of the building’s luxury amenities will wrap up in early 2027. Visualization One
There will also be a jewel-toned billiards room for homeowners. Visualisation One

Pricing across the 36 sellable units ranges from just under $11 million for a three bedroom to $58.5 million for the penthouse spanning the 21st floor. But not all units have hit the market yet, a representative for Corcoran Sunshine Marketing Group told The Post.

Sales launched quietly last fall, publicly early this year, and momentum has only built since.

In March, a buyer signed for the seventh floor at an asking price of $30.5 million, a unit originally planned as two separate apartments before the developers combined them into a single 7,700-square-foot home with ceilings over 10 feet tall. That deal briefly stood as the priciest inked at the building, a record since eclipsed as contracts have piled up on higher floors.

Amenities inside include a 60-foot lap pool, a fitness center, a sauna, a cold plunge pool, a billiards room and a residents’ lounge with a kitchenette — all tucked into a structure that was never designed to house any of it.

Construction crews have spent recent months replacing roughly 1,000 windows to landmark preservation specifications and installing the building’s first-ever exterior lighting scheme, details that have required extensive sign off given the Flatiron’s protected status.

Residences are expected to be move-in ready this fall, with the building’s full amenity package, including the lap pool, slated to open in early 2027.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *