Taking care of your teeth isn’t as simple as a quick brush and rinse. In fact, new data indicates that you should be paying extra attention to what products you’re putting inside your mouth.

On Monday, Oct. 19, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) reported a Class II recall of more than four million tubes of toothpaste. The recall was initiated in September for “CGMP deviations.” More recently, concerns that the items can cause temporary health problems have come to light. Even more alarming: The majority of the 17 products in question are for kids.

The toothpaste is distributed by Ashtel Studios under Brush Buddies, evo and ARU. Shoppers likely aren’t privy to the risk when painting on Barbie bubble gum-flavored or “My Little Pony”-adorned tube.

But there’s no need to panic. Not every dental product comes with a risk. Crest Pro-Health Advanced Antibacterial Protection Toothpaste is safe and trusted here at the Post, and right now, it’s even 10% off at Amazon.

The dentist-designed formula provides clinically-proven protection against cavities, plaque, gingivitis, tartar and tooth sensitivity. Using it consistently will also help to whiten teeth, fight acid erosion and support fresh breath with its mint burst flavor.

If you struggle from plaque in particular, the toothpaste contains patented stannous fluoride that counteracts harmful bacteria and improves overall gum health.

My teeth can be super sensitive, but this product blocks pain triggers and actively strengthens weak enamel.

With over 14,000 positive reviews, and nearly 90% of those ratings at five stars, it’s no secret shoppers are satisfied.

“Crest Pro-Health is a fantastic toothpaste! It leaves my teeth feeling incredibly clean and my breath fresh for hours. The mint flavor is refreshing without being too overpowering, and it’s gentle on my teeth and gums,” one person said.

Another added, “This Crest Pro-Health Advanced Antibacterial Protection toothpaste in the four-pack is a dependable choice for everyday oral care. If you’re after a toothpaste that tackles more than just surface stains, this one delivers a solid balance of cleanliness and freshness without feeling harsh.”

Don’t let the latest toothpaste recall scare you too much, but take a good look at your bathroom cabinet. It might be time to invest in Crest Pro-Health Advanced Antibacterial Protection Toothpaste, sold in a four pack for just $13.

This article was written by Carrie Berk, Commerce Reporter for the New York Post. Carrie specializes in New York City-ready fashion finds for every style, age and budget. Combing the internet’s sale sections, brand collaborations, seasonal trends, timeless staples and lookalike styles, she makes recommendations that stand the test of time in your wardrobe – without breaking the bank. Before joining The Post full time in 2026, her work appeared in HuffPost, Women’s Health, Newsweek and more.