NYC Council bans ‘surveillance pricing’ that has customers’ data used against them

The City Council passed a bill to prohibit “surveillance pricing” Thursday, blocking companies from using browsing data to charge customers different prices for the same product.

The bill was one of several pieces of legislation that lawmakers took up during their meeting Thursday, as they passed opted into a state program to exempt disabled veterans from property taxes while discussing a proposal to address terminal vacancies in rent-stabilized units.

New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin speaks during a council meeting in New York City on Thursday, Oct. 22, 2026, ahead of a vote on Ryder’s Law. Andrew Schwartz / SplashNews.com

The surveillance pricing law, which has the support of Mayor Zohran Mamdani, easily passed the Democrat-dominated council in a 44-5 vote.

“There are many factors that are driving up costs,” City Council Speaker Julie Menin, who sponsored the bill, said at City Hall ahead of the vote. “Some of them are quite obvious to consumers, but a more subtle reason is the insidious and predatory corporate practice of surveillance pricing.

“For different consumers that are shopping at the exact same time, companies set different prices for the exact same product, taking advantage of their demographics, web browsing history, and shopping habits, as well as their social media activity, all to make New Yorkers pay more,” she added. 

Critics of the bill were concerned the regulations would harm small businesses. But the final language of the bill allows wiggle room for smaller companies.

Members of the public attend a New York City Council Committee on Technology hearing on artificial intelligence safety at City Hall in New York, Oct. 16, 2026. ZUMAPRESS.com

Larger companies would be immediately hit with a $1,000 fine for violating the new pricing law — but small businesses will have the opportunity to first present an action plan to remedy any missteps.

A new bill under consideration would address the city’s over 50,000 vacant rent-stabilized apartments that have remained empty despite the city facing a vacancy of only 1.4%. Critics say landlords are “warehousing” units, intentionally keeping them empty rather than renting them out.

The newly introduced bill, sponsored by Brooklyn Council Member Farah Louis (D-45), would require the Department of Housing Preservation and Development to analyze and develop a plan over the course of 60 days to bring the vacant rent-stabilized stock online. 

“With approximately 57,000 reported vacant rent-stabilized units citywide and nearly 279,000 rent-stabilized apartments in Brooklyn alone, we need a clearer understanding of why these homes remain unavailable and what it will take to return them to the rental market,” Louis said in a statement.

New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin attends a City Council stated meeting at City Hall in New York on Thursday, May 14, 2026. James Keivom for NY Post

Lawmakers also approved a bill sponsored by Republican Councilman Frank Morano (R-51) to opt the city into to an Empire State law law that exempts “permanently and totally” disabled veterans from having to pay property taxes. 

“The state bill required an opt-in, and today what we’re doing in New York City is we are opting in, and we’re making a very powerful statement about how this council values its veterans,” Morano said at City Hall ahead of the bill’s vote. 

The legislation passed one day after Veterans Day – with a vote of 48-1. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *